Spacer between wheel bearings
-
- Oil Injector
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 8:33 pm
- Location: east yorkshire
Spacer between wheel bearings
Hi everyone,
I know there was a post about this the other day, my question is slightly different though.
After getting my wheels powdercoated and buying new bearings etc. i'm at the stage of reassembly. The spacer between the bearings is made of steel, is there any reason why i couldn't turn one up out of aluminium to save a bit of weight?
Would aluminium be upto the job?
Anybody done similar?
Maccas
I know there was a post about this the other day, my question is slightly different though.
After getting my wheels powdercoated and buying new bearings etc. i'm at the stage of reassembly. The spacer between the bearings is made of steel, is there any reason why i couldn't turn one up out of aluminium to save a bit of weight?
Would aluminium be upto the job?
Anybody done similar?
Maccas
- Howie
- Avgas Sniffer
- Posts: 2055
- Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2009 9:33 pm
- Location: East Yorkshire
To be honest Maccas, the weight saving would be so small it is not really worth worrying about.
Save yourself a few bob or lose ooh maybe a gram or two in your own body weight & then you may notice some difference.
My interest at the mo is the weight difference between the Kr1 wheels & the Kr1s wheels.
I'm going to weigh the buggers tomorrow because I have a theory about the wheel size vs the weight vs the disc size vs the brake calipers vs the way we use them
Obviously I could be wrong but hey ho
Save yourself a few bob or lose ooh maybe a gram or two in your own body weight & then you may notice some difference.
My interest at the mo is the weight difference between the Kr1 wheels & the Kr1s wheels.
I'm going to weigh the buggers tomorrow because I have a theory about the wheel size vs the weight vs the disc size vs the brake calipers vs the way we use them
Obviously I could be wrong but hey ho
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1382
- Joined: Tue Jul 25, 2006 11:34 am
- Location: South Wales (Old)
- Contact:
-
- Oil Injector
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 8:33 pm
- Location: east yorkshire
- Howie
- Avgas Sniffer
- Posts: 2055
- Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2009 9:33 pm
- Location: East Yorkshire
Yep, exactly the same Al. I started thinking about it when I was clearing up in my parts shed & had a Kr1 rear in one hand & a 1s rear in the other.Could your theory be the same as mine
As for the bearing spacer, I don't see why not. The Zx6r's have aluminium spacers in the front wheel & possibly the rear too.
There is no 'load' on them as such. I would go for it maccas.
- JanBros
- Avgas Sniffer
- Posts: 3306
- Joined: Wed Jul 26, 2006 11:50 pm
- Location: the land of Francorchamps
aluminium will be just fine, I make all my spacers out off aluminium.
and Howie : there isn't any part on any bike that you can save 10 kilo's on (unless you have money for carbon wheels/discs ), so real weight saving comes down to every little bit off anything, and only when you add them up, you'll get significant numbers
and Howie : there isn't any part on any bike that you can save 10 kilo's on (unless you have money for carbon wheels/discs ), so real weight saving comes down to every little bit off anything, and only when you add them up, you'll get significant numbers
My ultimate goal is to die young as late as possible !
-
- Oil Injector
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 8:33 pm
- Location: east yorkshire
-
- Oil Injector
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 8:33 pm
- Location: east yorkshire
Right because i just know that everyone was dying to know how much weight could be saved by making aluminium wheel bearing spacers i have sat and worked it out at university today because i was bored.
The weights of the standard spacers are as follows:
Front: 143.12g
Rear: 123.68g
Now i have turned two bits of aluminium down the correct sizes and i just need to drill the 17mm hole through the middle.
I weighed the new bits as they are and measured their dimensions accurately and worked out the density of the aluminium as: 2757.86 kg/m^3
Now when you plug this new density into the required volume of the new spacers you get:
Front: 52.8g
Rear: 45.4g
So a grand weight saving total of (drum roll please)
((143.12+123.68 ) - (52.8+45.4)) = 168.6g
I'm sure lots of other similar savings can be made elsewhere, i'm going to look into making an aluminium front fairing bracket next i think!
Would aluminium be any good for wheel spindles or would i have to fork out for titanium to save some weight on those?
Maccas
The weights of the standard spacers are as follows:
Front: 143.12g
Rear: 123.68g
Now i have turned two bits of aluminium down the correct sizes and i just need to drill the 17mm hole through the middle.
I weighed the new bits as they are and measured their dimensions accurately and worked out the density of the aluminium as: 2757.86 kg/m^3
Now when you plug this new density into the required volume of the new spacers you get:
Front: 52.8g
Rear: 45.4g
So a grand weight saving total of (drum roll please)
((143.12+123.68 ) - (52.8+45.4)) = 168.6g
I'm sure lots of other similar savings can be made elsewhere, i'm going to look into making an aluminium front fairing bracket next i think!
Would aluminium be any good for wheel spindles or would i have to fork out for titanium to save some weight on those?
Maccas
- pablo
- Premix Junkie
- Posts: 1546
- Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2008 9:37 pm
- Location: Co Durham
-
- Oil Injector
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 8:33 pm
- Location: east yorkshire
-
- Oil Injector
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 8:33 pm
- Location: east yorkshire
-
- Oil Injector
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 8:33 pm
- Location: east yorkshire
-
- Premix Junkie
- Posts: 1587
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 2:24 am
.
.
aluminium for the spacers.... OK
STEEL only for the axle ... having bent a (slender) KR-1 front axle in a minor myself
lightweights such as R1/R6/GSXR... all have hollow STEEL and its probably not only just for cost they are very light and might be mistaken for alu
SOME (exotic bikes) are alloy/aluminium but in much greater diameters - rigidity design
...theres 500g to be saved in the (840g) KIPS servo
... someone should really start a spreadsheet with exact weights of every part and lightweight options
an R6 radial Sumitomo (monoblock - no bolt together) caliper weighs ~950g (with pads) each
the Tokico common radial equivalent.... 1150g
thats ~400g saving in unsprung weight (for two)
a CBR600 front wheel (3 spoke with disks)... 6.9kg
an R6 front wheel (5 spoke similar modern year)... 7.2kg
thats a further 300g saving in unsprung weight
.
aluminium for the spacers.... OK
STEEL only for the axle ... having bent a (slender) KR-1 front axle in a minor myself
lightweights such as R1/R6/GSXR... all have hollow STEEL and its probably not only just for cost they are very light and might be mistaken for alu
SOME (exotic bikes) are alloy/aluminium but in much greater diameters - rigidity design
...theres 500g to be saved in the (840g) KIPS servo
... someone should really start a spreadsheet with exact weights of every part and lightweight options
an R6 radial Sumitomo (monoblock - no bolt together) caliper weighs ~950g (with pads) each
the Tokico common radial equivalent.... 1150g
thats ~400g saving in unsprung weight (for two)
a CBR600 front wheel (3 spoke with disks)... 6.9kg
an R6 front wheel (5 spoke similar modern year)... 7.2kg
thats a further 300g saving in unsprung weight