I forgot to mention as with any sort of welding the temperature is quite important.
If the plastic you are working with is starting to bubble, it is way too hot. This will cause the weld to fail as you have broken the molecular chains in the plastic.
The fumes, particularly from ABS are a bit nasty, a well ventilated work area (garden table) is recommended.
Scooble, JB weld won't do the job for any length of time. The problem with plastic is, it is full of plasticiser to make it, well, plastic.... JB weld is a surface bonding agent and does not react with the plastic, so as the plasticiser leaches out over time the joint fails and it comes off.
The only stuff you can buy that will dissolve ABS is a liquid called MEK (Methyl Ethyl Ketone) This will stick ABS together, but again you will need a filler rod, because the plastic shrinks when you use MEK.
It sounds like you either did not heat the panel enough to get the filler to bond, or the filler was not the same as the panel. Pretty much all panels now are marked somewhere (they have to be by recycling laws). The ones marked GF are the worst to do. They contain glass fiber filler of varying percentage to stiffen the panel, but because of this they require a high temperature to melt them, and the control of the weld is difficult. Kawasaki used GF panels on the ZXR range form 1991 through to 1996, and they are a right PIA to work on.
If you are using a soldering iron type one, try to work from the middle then an end then the other end of the work piece. This will prevent over stressing the crack/join. Always drill the end of any crack/join and over fill. Oh and I always melt the panel first and then add the filler to the panel. Not sure if any instruction mention this, but getting the panel hot first seems to make a very good weld. Maybe I'm a bit odd too, but I do the reverse side first and then vee out the outer surface and do it again.
Oh and make sure you get all the paint off before you start. Paint and plastic do not make good welds!
